Home / News / Flat Traffic, No Budget? Ziff Davis’ Test to Jump AI Visibility
Flat Traffic, No Budget? Ziff Davis’ Test to Jump AI Visibility
Ziff Davis VP Jonathan Berthold reveals the first low‑budget experiment to break flat traffic and capture AI‑driven search. Business owners can apply his playbook to get noticed by ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google AI Overviews.
Key Highlights
- ✓Berthold’s first test targeted bottom‑of‑funnel pages, not just traffic volume.
- ✓A $250 micro‑budget experiment delivered measurable lift in AI citations.
- ✓14‑day evaluation period is enough to prove ROI to leadership.
- ✓AI‑friendly schema markup is a low‑cost way to get cited by ChatGPT and Google AI.
What Happened
In a recent Search Engine Journal podcast, Jonathan Berthold – VP of Revenue at Ziff Davis – answered a question that many small‑business marketers face: "Your traffic is flat and you have no extra budget. What do you test first?" Berthold walked through the exact experiment his team launched, the metrics they tracked, and how they convinced leadership to green‑light a modest spend.
Key Details
- Focus on the bottom‑of‑funnel (BoF) gap – Instead of chasing more clicks, Berthold looked at what happens after a user lands on the site. He identified low‑conversion pages and tested micro‑optimizations that cost almost nothing.
- Micro‑budget test – The experiment used a $250 spend split between a narrow‑target paid search ad group and a quick‑win SEO tweak (adding structured data for AI snippets).
- Speedy timeline – Results were evaluated after 14 days. The rule of thumb: give a test at least two weeks to gather enough impressions for statistical relevance.
- Clear KPI – The team measured conversion‑rate lift and AI citation frequency (how often the page appeared in ChatGPT‑generated answers or Google AI Overviews), not just raw traffic.
What It Means For Your Business
If you run a local shop, a niche SaaS, or any small‑to‑mid‑size brand, the same principles apply:
1. Stop treating traffic as the end goal. AI tools now surface answers directly, pulling content from the web. If your page isn’t optimized for AI citation, you’ll stay invisible even with decent traffic.
2. Start small, think big. A $100‑$300 test can uncover a high‑impact tweak – like adding schema markup, improving page‑load speed, or crafting a laser‑focused ad copy that matches a high‑intent query.
3. Show leadership the ROI in minutes, not months. By tying the experiment to a concrete business outcome (e.g., a 15% lift in qualified leads), you make it easier to secure future budgets.
Actionable Steps for Small Business Marketers
| Step | What to Do | Why It Works |
|------|------------|--------------|
| 1. Audit the BoF funnel | Identify the top 3 pages where visitors drop off before converting. Use Google Analytics or Heatmaps. | Pinpoints the low‑ hanging fruit where a tiny change can move the needle. |
| 2. Add AI‑friendly markup | Implement FAQ schema, Product schema, and cite-as tags where relevant. | Increases the chance AI models pull your content for direct answers. |
| 3. Run a micro‑paid test | Create a single‑keyword ad group with $5‑$10 daily budget targeting a high‑intent phrase. | Generates immediate traffic to test the new markup and conversion flow. |
| 4. Track AI citations | Use tools like VisibilityAI, Ahrefs’ AI SERP tracker, or manual searches in ChatGPT/Perplexity. | Gives you a metric that matters to AI‑first search ecosystems. |
| 5. Review after 14 days | Compare conversion rates and AI citation counts to baseline. | Provides a data‑driven story you can present to leadership. |
Keep the Test Small Enough Not to Hurt the Site
Berthold warned that a test should never jeopardize site stability. By limiting the spend, targeting a single landing page, and using a feature flag to roll out changes, you protect the broader user experience while still learning fast.
The Bigger Picture: AI‑First Discovery
Search is evolving from keyword lists to answer engines. Platforms like ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Google AI Overviews now pull content directly from the web to answer user questions. For local businesses, being cited in these answers can be worth more than a traditional SERP ranking because users get the information without clicking away.
How VisibilityAI Amplifies This Strategy
VisibilityAI specializes in ensuring that your content is AI‑ready:
- Schema automation – We generate and inject the right structured data at scale.
- Citation monitoring – Real‑time alerts when your brand appears in AI‑generated answers.
- Optimization recommendations – Tailored suggestions to improve relevance for AI queries.
By pairing Berthold’s low‑budget test framework with VisibilityAI’s tooling, you can accelerate the path from flat traffic to AI‑driven leads.
Bottom Line
Flat traffic doesn’t have to mean a dead end. A disciplined, low‑cost experiment that focuses on post‑click experience and AI citation can unlock new visibility channels. Use the steps above, leverage VisibilityAI’s platform, and you’ll be ready to show your boss measurable results – even on a shoestring budget.
---
Ready to run your first AI‑focused test? [Start a free trial with VisibilityAI today](https://www.visibilityai.com).
Why This Matters For Your Business
In an AI‑first search landscape, traditional traffic metrics are no longer the sole indicator of success. When users receive answers directly from tools like ChatGPT or Google AI Overviews, the chance to be *cited* becomes the new premium real estate. For small businesses trying to compete with larger brands, securing those citations can drive qualified leads without the need for massive ad spends. VisibilityAI’s mission is to make that AI citation process transparent and scalable. By ensuring your pages are properly marked up, monitoring where your brand appears in AI answers, and providing actionable optimization tips, VisibilityAI turns a modest test into a sustainable growth engine. This means you can keep your marketing budget lean while still appearing in the AI‑driven conversations that today’s consumers are having. In short, mastering low‑budget testing and AI‑ready content gives you a competitive edge: you stay visible, you prove ROI quickly, and you future‑proof your digital presence against the next wave of search technology.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the minimum budget needed to run a test like Jonathan Berthold’s?
Berthold’s experiment used roughly $250 total – about $5‑$10 per day on a tightly scoped paid search ad and a few hours of SEO work. The key is to keep the spend focused on a single page or keyword.
How do I measure if my page is being cited by AI tools?
Use AI‑citation monitoring tools (e.g., VisibilityAI), set up Google Alerts for your brand, or manually search queries in ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini to see if your content appears in the answer snippets.
Can I apply this test if I don’t have a paid media budget?
Yes. You can run a purely organic test by adding schema markup, improving page speed, and promoting the page through low‑cost channels like community posts or email newsletters. Track the same AI citation and conversion metrics.
Is your business showing up in AI search?
Get your free AI visibility audit - see if ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google AI actually recommend you.